1

I've got table of scores where each entry corresponds to a particular (student, subject) pair.

CREATE TABLE score (
  id serial PRIMARY KEY,
  value integer NOT NULL,
  subject_id integer NOT NULL,
  student_id integer NOT NULL,
  CONSTRAINT s1_id FOREIGN KEY (subject_id) REFERENCES subject (id),
  CONSTRAINT s2_id FOREIGN KEY (student_id) REFERENCES student (id),
);

I want to pick the top 5 subjects with highest overall scores, and then compute the average score of each student across those 5 subjects. Some students may not have entries for some subjects. Those values would be given a default score.

Here's what I have:

SELECT student_id, AVG(COALESCE(score.value, default_value)) FROM 
(
    SELECT score.subject_id, subject.name, SUM(score.value) AS score_sum
    FROM score
    JOIN subject on subject.id = score.subject_id
    WHERE subject.name != 'skip me'
    GROUP BY score.subject_id
    ORDER BY score_sum DESC
    LIMIT 5
) AS score_sort
LEFT JOIN score ON score_sort.subject_id = score.subject_id 
GROUP BY student_id

The inner query works correctly to select the top 5. But the LEFT JOIN in outer query does not select the rows where a student does not have a score. What am I doing wrong here ?

1 Answer 1

3

You could use a CROSS JOIN from score_sort to all the students and then a LEFT join to score:

SELECT st.student_id, 
       AVG(COALESCE(sc.value, default_value)) AS average_score
FROM 
(
    SELECT score.subject_id, subject.name, SUM(score.value) AS score_sum
    FROM score
    JOIN subject on subject.id = score.subject_id
    WHERE subject.name != 'skip me'
    GROUP BY score.subject_id
    ORDER BY score_sum DESC
    LIMIT 5
) AS score_sort AS sort 
  CROSS JOIN student AS st
  LEFT JOIN score AS sc
    ON  sort.subject_id = sc.subject_id 
    AND   st.student_id = sc.student_id
GROUP BY st.student_id ;

A different approach would be to alter your query to count the available scores each student has (in the 5 top subjects):

SELECT score.student_id, 
       (SUM(score.value) + (5 - COUNT(score.subject_id)) * default_value) / 5 
           AS average_score
FROM 
(
    SELECT score.subject_id, subject.name, SUM(score.value) AS score_sum
    FROM score
    JOIN subject on subject.id = score.subject_id
    WHERE subject.name != 'skip me'
    GROUP BY score.subject_id
    ORDER BY score_sum DESC
    LIMIT 5
) AS score_sort
JOIN score ON score_sort.subject_id = score.subject_id 
GROUP BY score.student_id ;

But even with this, you would still not get any result for the students that have no score in any of the 5 top subjects.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.