2

Who were the first creators of the Identity column? What problem were those creators originally trying to solve? Is there a story behind it?

3

1 Answer 1

4

Hi Bob and welcome to DBSE.

I assume (correct me if I'm wrong) that your question is not about the specific properties of SQL Server or Oracle IDENTITY, but about the use of IDENTITY as surrogate keys in general, which will be true for other implementations such as AUTO_INCREMENT, SEQUENCE, IDENTITY, GUIDs, OID as a design choice.

If that is what you mean, I salute you for this inquiry. Most people new to SQL never stop to ask these questions and just assume 'this is how it's done' because everybody seems to be doing it this way.

This is a controversial topic, and you will find people with strong opinions both ways. A quick search for "Natural Vs. Surrogate keys / artificial keys" will yield you enough reading material for years.

Wikipedia has a nice article that will get you started. Joe Celko also wrote quite a few excellent articles about this topic, you can start with this one, and this one.

I also find this video session on the subject to be entertaining and educational.

I am of the opinion that both are valid solutions. However, I also see that surrogate keys are used indiscriminately by most, just because finding the correct keys and modeling it properly is a significant effort, that requires mastering the relational model, which is hard.

IMHO, that is unfortunately also the root cause of many data consistency, modularity, performance, coding, and manageability challenges that later end up very hard and very expensive to correct.

Ask anyone who has ever tried to merge two data sets that use surrogate keys. At that point, you have no choice but to look for the natural key. But, if the natural keys were never explored, or properly constrained with UNIQUE constraints, the inconsistencies and duplicates are typically in abundance.

In my designs, I find that I use natural keys for the majority of the tables, and carefully plan for the edge cases where a surrogate is beneficial. These design choice are very much a minority opinion.

HTH

1
  • 1
    Thank you for your response SQLRaptor. I think you must have misunderstood my question. I was simply interested in the historical facts, not modern database design debates. @MDCCL answered my question in the comment below my question..
    – Bob
    Commented Nov 29, 2018 at 20:48

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.