I have two indexes that index the same field on the same table. The only difference between them is the included columns.
There's no reason I shouldn't combine the included columns and just have one index, right?
Yes, you should merge these indexes and only keep one, as long as you verify that:
Neither of them are marked as
UNIQUE (in which case, preserve that one)
Neither of them have a filter condition
Neither of them are expressly referenced in an index hint