Escalation, though
Lock escalation under serializable isolation level may occur the same as it does with other isolation levels.
- Correct indexes can help to avoid lock escalation up to a point
- Locking many indexes will increase the likelihood of lock escalation; the count is cumulative across objects for a single statement
Some quick examples using a single table with a single index. Id is the primary key and clustered index on the table.
One Row
SET TRANSACTION ISOLATION LEVEL SERIALIZABLE
BEGIN TRAN
UPDATE c
SET c.Score = 2147483647
FROM dbo.Comments AS c
WHERE c.Id = 138; --One value
ROLLBACK
For a single Id value, locking is minimal.
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
| request_mode | locked_object | resource_type | total_locks |
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
| RangeX-X | Comments | KEY | 1 |
| IX | Comments | OBJECT | 1 |
| IX | Comments | PAGE | 1 |
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
Multiple Rows
But locks will go up if we start working in ranges:
SET TRANSACTION ISOLATION LEVEL SERIALIZABLE
BEGIN TRAN
UPDATE c
SET c.Score = 2147483647
FROM dbo.Comments AS c
WHERE c.Id BETWEEN 1 AND 5000; -- Small range
ROLLBACK
Now we have more exclusive locks on more keys:
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
| request_mode | locked_object | resource_type | total_locks |
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
| RangeX-X | Comments | KEY | 2429 |
| IX | Comments | OBJECT | 1 |
| IX | Comments | PAGE | 97 |
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
Way More Rows
This will carry on until we hit a tipping point:
SET TRANSACTION ISOLATION LEVEL SERIALIZABLE
BEGIN TRAN
UPDATE c
SET c.Score = 2147483647
FROM dbo.Comments AS c
WHERE c.Id BETWEEN 1 AND 11655; --Larger range
ROLLBACK
Lock escalation is attempted and is successful:
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
| request_mode | locked_object | resource_type | total_locks |
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
| X | Comments | OBJECT | 1 |
+--------------+---------------+---------------+-------------+
Pay Attention
It's important to separate two concepts here: the isolation level will be serializable no matter what kind of locks are taken. The query chooses the isolation level, and the storage engine chooses the locks. Serializable won't always result in range locks -- the storage engine can pick whichever kind of locks still honor the isolation level.