-1

For example,

  • MOVIES (movieid, movietitle)

where movietitle can be any number of words, so I believe it's not atomic.

How do you bring something like that to 1NF?

  • What's the specific domain of movietitle? What are the constraints that apply to that domain? Do you have a real-world and representative set of sample values of that domain? Also, the post so far lacks any description of the business environment of relevance, so please address that issue. – MDCCL Oct 2 at 21:21
  • As it stands, an answer like this suffices. – MDCCL Oct 2 at 21:22
  • A movie title, regardless of how many words (or characters) are in it, is an atomic value. – mustaccio Oct 2 at 21:31
  • The comment above is correct as long as a given movietitle occurrence corresponds to exactly one value of the respective simple domain, but we don't know what the domain is in this very particular case; therefore, for the time being, it's impossible to determine with the precision demanded in professional database design all the aspects around first normal form in the scenario at hand. – MDCCL Oct 2 at 21:39
1

Atomic in this sense is a logical concept. Would you consider the integer 123 not atomic because it has more than one digit? 123 is an agreed upon singular fact, representing a point on the numbers axis. A movie title is the same - it represents a singular agreed upon fact, that a movie with that title exists in the real world. A non atomic value would be “rocky, rocky 2” - a value that specifies 2 facts , and that would violate 1NF. Same would go for the integer 123, if each digit represents a different fact. For example if 1 represents an item color code and the 23 its size.

HTH

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.