I have a basic question on how JOIN works on multiple tables. I want to count occurrences of Foreign Key in link1 & link2

   name text NOT NULL

   main_id integer NOT NULL,
   CONSTRAINT main_id_fk FOREIGN KEY (main_id) REFERENCES main (id)

-- link2 is similar to link1

SQL Fiddle

Why does the query below give a product of counts (rather than sum) when the count is non-zero in both columns.

SELECT main.id, COUNT(link1.main_id) + COUNT(link2.main_id)
FROM main
LEFT JOIN link1 ON main.id=link1.main_id
LEFT JOIN link2 ON main.id=link2.main_id
GROUP BY main.id

What you see is a "proxy cross join". Aggregate first, then join:

SELECT m.id, COALESCE(l1.ct, 0) + COALESCE(l2.ct, 0) AS total_ct
FROM   main m
   SELECT main_id, count(*) AS ct
   FROM   link1
   GROUP  BY main_id
   ) l1 ON l1.main_id = m.id
   SELECT main_id, count(*) AS ct
   FROM   link2
   GROUP  BY main_id
   ) l2 ON l2.main_id = m.id
ORDER BY m.id;

SQL Fiddle.

Do not multiply rows with multiple unqualified joins and count(DISTINCT ...) later to fix the mistake. It happens to work in this case since counting DISTINCT link1.id / link2.id coincides with the desired result, but it's needlessly expensive and error prone.

Detailed explanation and a couple of syntax variants in these related answers on SO:

  • 3
    This has a better performance & works well for my usecase. It should be the accepted answer
    – phil
    Mar 8 '18 at 10:03

I'll attempt to answer it myself. Consider a LEFT JOIN between main & link1. The output would be

main.id   link1.main_id
   1          1
   1          1
   2          2
   3         NULL  
   4         NULL  

Now do a LEFT JOIN of the above table with link2, output would be:

main.id    link1.main_id    link2.main_id
   1             1               NULL  
   1             1               NULL  
   2             2                2
   2             2                2     -- Error : double counting for link1
   3            NULL              3
   4            NULL                   

Now count the occurrences of main_id & sum them (grouped by main.id)

main.id        Count
   1             2
   2             2 + 2  
   3             1
   4             0

So two successive LEFT JOIN are happening sequentially rather than in parallel. The correct approach to get the count would be do conduct 2 queries separately and then add the results

Update Another way according to @a1ex07 is

SELECT main.id, COUNT(DISTINCT link1.id) + COUNT(DISTINCT link2.id)
FROM main
LEFT JOIN link1 ON main.id=link1.main_id
LEFT JOIN link2 ON main.id=link2.main_id
GROUP BY main.id
  • You seem to confuse 0 with NULL . The first 2 outputs won't have any zeros. link1.main_id and link2.main_id might be either equals to main.id or NULL. And why not just COUNT(DISTINCT link1.id) + COUNT(DISTINCT link2.id) ?
    – a1ex07
    Dec 30 '14 at 15:00
  • @a1ex07 Thanks for pointing out about NULL. I'll update the answer. Regarding DISTINCT, I want the count to reflect multiple entries in any table. Dec 30 '14 at 15:06
  • 1
    I believe distinct will do that (note, it's counting distinct link1.id and link2.id, not link1.main_id/ link2.main_id ). Thus, in your example for main.id = 2 there will be 1 distinct link1.id and 2 distinct link2.id...
    – a1ex07
    Dec 30 '14 at 15:24
  • Right, updated the answer. Cool technique. Dec 30 '14 at 17:36
  • 2
    @a1ex07: While DISTINCT does the trick here, it's a bit like putting lipstick on a pig ... Jan 3 '15 at 5:35

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.