You have NULLs that violate the CHECK CONSTRAINT. To verify that this is indeed the problem, run this SQL. SELECT * FROM integrations.accounts WHERE qb_settings IS NOT NULL OR xero_settings IS NOT NULL OR... (fill in the fields that correspond to those in the CONSTRAINT). This will give you all the records that have fields which have a NULL value which violate the CONSTRAINT. From your SQL, you have 59 such records - that's why you're getting the error. What you need to do to rectify this is to run SQL similar to the following: UPDATE My_Table SET My_Field = 0 WHERE My_Field IS NULL. Obviously it is up to you to ensure that the values that you set correspond to your system's business logic and other system requirements.